Why Yelling Isn't Working with Your Kids: Compassionate Parenting Techniques for a Peaceful Home
- Kimberly Broman
- May 17, 2024
- 3 min read

As a millennial mom navigating the chaos of parenting, have you ever found yourself yelling at your kids in sheer frustration, only to realize it wasn’t effective? You're not alone. Many of us have been there, feeling overwhelmed and desperate for a solution that actually works. As someone who grew up with a parent who yelled often, I knew that yelling was something I did not want to do with my own kids. I knew I wanted to be a better parent than the one I had so I needed to educate myself on how exactly I needed to do that. Let’s dive into why yelling isn’t the answer and explore some compassionate parenting techniques that can help us raise emotionally intelligent, well-behaved children and overall have a more peaceful home.
As the child of an immigrant single mother who had an estranged relationship with her own mother, my house always felt like a battleground. My mother would yell, scream, and whoop us because that's how she was raised. Without a real model of compassionate parenting, I feared I would continue the cycle of yelling, screaming, and whooping, which I knew was not effective.
When I became an educator, I underwent extensive training about the ineffectiveness and harm of punitive punishment. I learned a lot about restorative processes and how empathy was at the center of it all. Through all my research and experience with my child, here's what I've learned:
Why Yelling Doesn't Work:
Stress Response: When we yell, our children enter a fight-or-flight mode, shutting down their ability to listen and reason.
Emotional Impact: Yelling can damage a child's self-esteem, leading to feelings of fear and resentment rather than respect and understanding.
Ineffectiveness: Consistent yelling often leads to children becoming desensitized, causing the behavior to persist or even worsen.
Alternatives to Yelling:
Take a Break: When you feel the urge to yell, take a moment to breathe deeply and calm yourself. Stepping away for a few minutes can help you regain control and approach the situation more rationally.
Use a Calm Voice: Speak in a firm but calm voice. This encourages your child to listen and respond without feeling threatened or scared.
Set Clear Expectations: Clearly communicate rules and consequences in advance. Consistency is key. When children know what to expect, they are less likely to push boundaries.
Consistent Routines: Predictable routines provide a sense of security and reduce the need for disciplinary measures.
Restorative Practices: These involve understanding the impact of one's actions and making amends. It's about repairing harm and fostering a sense of accountability and community. Hitting your child or yelling at your child doesn't help them understand their actions and make amends. It teaches them that hitting and yelling are okay.
Positive Reinforcement: Praise and reward good behavior. Acknowledging their efforts encourages them to continue making positive choices instead of focusing on the negative.
Empathy and Understanding: Try to understand the root cause of your child's behavior. Are they tired, hungry, or seeking attention? Addressing their needs can often prevent outbursts. Understanding your child's perspective and feelings can transform your approach to discipline. Instead of reacting with anger, respond with empathy.
Engaging Alternatives:
Interactive Time-Outs: Instead of a traditional time-out, sit with your child and talk about their feelings and actions. This can help them understand and reflect on their behavior.
Role-Playing: Use role-playing games to teach your child about appropriate behavior and reactions. This can be a fun and educational way to address issues.
Resources:
Books:
"Raising an Emotionally Intelligent Child" by John Gottman
"The Whole-Brain Child" by Daniel J. Siegel and Tina Payne Bryson
"No-Drama Discipline" by Daniel J. Siegel and Tina Payne Bryson
Online Support:
Parenting groups on social media platforms such as Facebook
Websites like Positive Parenting Solutions and Aha! Parenting
My relationship with my child is much healthier, and my home is more peaceful than the one I grew up in. That, in itself, is a huge win for me. By incorporating these strategies, not only can we better manage our
stress, but we can also foster a more positive and supportive environment for our children. Let’s commit to being the best versions of ourselves for our children.
Transitioning away from yelling isn't easy, but it's worth it. By adopting new strategies and seeking out resources, we can create a more harmonious home environment. Remember, it's a journey, and it's okay to seek support along the way. Let’s break the cycle of yelling and embrace more effective and compassionate ways to connect with our kids.
Have you tried any of these alternatives to yelling? Share your experiences in the comments below, and let's support each other in this journey of mindful parenting. If you found this blog helpful, please share it with other moms who might benefit from these tips. Together, we can create a community of empowered, calm, and connected parents.
댓글